One of sour, two of sweet; three of strong and four of weak. That’s the traditional guideline for making a classic Caribbean rum punch. I enjoy a classic Caribbean rum punch, I do. But sometimes I want something a little less sour and a little more sweet. I like the kind of rum punch that sneaks up on you and makes you believe it’s little more than just an innocent tropical juice, before it gets you in trouble. I guess my measurement preference is more like one of sour, three of sweet, three of strong and four of weak. Or something.


Trinidad is known for many things, and one of those things is RUM. We make some amazing rums. I am a fan of the House of Angostura , from 1824 on down. But sometimes real Trini rum is hard to find in Chicago. So when my friends at Sailor Jerry rum gifted me a bottle of their goodness, I immediately decided to make punch. But what KIND of punch? That remained to be seen.

Punch is super popular these days — here in Chicago there’s even a whole bar dedicated to the stuff that’s appropriately named Punch House. There are many kinds of  punch– Wikipedia goes into greater detail, mentioning  Southern Bourbon punch and “cups,” like Pimm’s Cups and the like. Wikipedia didn’t include New Orleans Milk Punch, and their rum punch section seems a bit subjective to me, but HEY. What do I know. You can click here for the very traditional Trinidadian rum punch recipe, via Chookooloonks by way of Trini Gourmet. And here’s what I used to make my own remix.

Sailor Jerry Rum Punch Afrobella 1


OK. So one of sour — I’ve got a lime. Two of sweet; I’ve got grenadine and simple syrup. Three of strong — that would be my Sailor Jerry rum and X-Rated Fusion LiqueurFour of weak, I threw in a whole lotta pineapple juice, plus water and the frozen apple/passion fruit/mango juice blend. I sliced a lime and blood orange and added bitters to taste. My recipe appears to be a lot more like a classic Planter’s Punch, which includes dark rum, pineapple juice, grenadine, sugar syrup and Angostura bitters. Hmmmm. Either way,  voila! 


Sailor Jerry Rum Punch Afrobella 2


It was so delicious! Here’s the recipe.

Afrobella’s Sailor Jerry Trini Rum Punch Recipe Remix

1 cup fresh lime juice

1/2 cup grenadine

2 cups Sailor Jerry

1 1/2 cups X-Rated Fusion Liqueur

1 can Dole Pineapple Juice

2 tablespoons simple syrup

1 tropical frozen juice of choice — I chose Old Orchard 100% Juice apple passion fruit mango blend

Blood orange slices for garnish

Lime slices for garnish

liberal splashes of Angostura Bitters to taste.

Mix it all together in your punch bowl or pitcher, serve over ice and with garnish of choice. Serves 6 to 8.



pets says:
February 3, 2016, 7:27 pm
Looks great! am sure it tastes fantastic! Yumpunch.
Melanese says:
February 4, 2016, 5:33 pm
Oh how I wish this were a printable recipe. Nevertheless, I will be making note of it. I live in Houston and we are privy to Old Oak and Puncheon, to name a few. Imagine my surprise when I saw it on the shelves. Will definitely be trying this one. Thanks for posting.
TheRealTPayne says:
February 4, 2016, 9:45 pm
I'll be making this over my birthday weekend!
Patrice - Nzuri Gold says:
February 17, 2016, 8:32 pm
This looks like the perfect amount of sour and sweet---I have to try this, thanks!